Serving Baytown, TX & Surrounding Areas(281) 691-0552
← All roofing articles

Roof Underlayment Types: Felt, Synthetic and Peel-and-Stick

Underlayment covering a bare roof deck

There are three main types of roof underlayment: asphalt-saturated felt, synthetic sheets, and self-adhering (peel-and-stick) membranes. Felt is the traditional, lowest-cost choice. Synthetic is lighter, stronger and made to last longer. Peel-and-stick costs the most and seals around nail holes, so it goes where leaks start: eaves, valleys, and around vents and chimneys. On a Gulf Coast roof, the right answer is often a combination, and the choice is easiest to make when a roofer shows you the actual condition of your deck before you sign anything.

Underlayment is the layer between your roof deck and your shingles. You never see it once the roof is finished, yet it is your second line of defense when wind-driven rain gets past a shingle. Here is what each type does, what it costs, and how to decide.

Sureclaimroofing
Make an Informed Roofing Decision
Sure Claim Roofing serves Baytown with roof repairs, replacements, and storm damage inspections, with honest explanations of your options.

TL;DR

  • The three types are felt, synthetic, and self-adhering (peel-and-stick). Each one does a different job under asphalt shingles.
  • Felt runs about $0.05 to $0.45 per square foot, synthetic about $0.15 to $0.70, according to Angi’s 2026 cost comparison. Peel-and-stick is the priciest per square foot.
  • Synthetic generally beats felt on water resistance, weight and tear strength. Peel-and-stick is best used strategically at leak-prone spots.
  • Texas wind and hail insurance standards for the coastal catastrophe area now spell out how underlayment must be installed, so ask which rules cover your address.
  • Get the underlayment written into your estimate by name and type, so you can compare bids honestly.

Table of Contents

What roof underlayment actually does

The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) describes underlayment as secondary protection from wind-driven rain and other moisture. It also keeps asphalt shingles from touching resins in the wood deck. Shingles shed most of the water. Underlayment handles what slips through at the edges, under tabs, or around a damaged spot during a storm.

It also protects a bare deck during construction. A roof tear-off can sit exposed to weather for a day or more, and the underlayment keeps rain out until the shingles go on.

That is why the material matters most in the moments you cannot see: a tropical downpour, a gust that lifts a shingle edge, or a hailstone that cracks a mat. In Baytown, where storms push rain sideways, that second layer earns its keep.

The three types of roof underlayment

ARMA lists the same three categories that most manufacturers use: asphalt-saturated felt, self-adhering underlayment, and non-asphaltic synthetic polymers. You may also see other names, such as tar paper or roofing felt (both mean felt), or ice and water shield (a peel-and-stick product).

Felt, synthetic, and self-adhering underlayment types

Asphalt-saturated felt

Felt is a sheet of organic or fiberglass material soaked in asphalt. It has been used under shingles for generations, which is why many contractors and inspectors know it so well. It comes in different weights, usually called 15-pound and 30-pound, with the heavier sheet being thicker and more tear-resistant.

Strengths: it is the lowest-priced option, widely available, and familiar to every crew. Angi puts felt at $0.05 to $0.45 per square foot, with a life of up to 30 years.

What to watch: felt is less water-resistant than synthetic and tears more easily. It can wrinkle if it gets wet before the shingles go on, and wrinkles can telegraph through the finished roof.

Synthetic underlayment

Synthetic underlayment is made from woven or spun plastics such as polypropylene or polyethylene. It is lighter than felt, so a single roll covers more area, and it is designed to resist tearing and moisture better.

Angi lists synthetic at $0.15 to $0.70 per square foot, with a lifespan of 25 to 50 years. It is lighter and more water-resistant than felt, though Angi notes it is more complicated to install. In practice that means crews need to follow each manufacturer’s fastening instructions closely, which often call for specific cap fasteners.

One technical difference is worth knowing. The Colorado Roofing Association points out that traditional felt has a perm rating of 3.0 to 5.0, which means moisture can pass through it, while many synthetic underlayments rate 0.1 or less and behave more like a vapor barrier. A perm rating measures how easily water vapor passes through a material. The lower the number, the less vapor gets through. This is the reason attic ventilation matters more as you add tighter layers. Our guide to roof ventilation requirements covers how vent sizing works.

Synthetic underlayment

Self-adhering (peel-and-stick) underlayment

Peel-and-stick is a rubberized asphalt membrane with a sticky back. You peel off the film and press it onto the deck. Fine Homebuilding explains that the sticky layer bonds to the sheathing and seals around nail shanks, which matters because an average asphalt-shingle roof has thousands of nails, and each one is a tiny hole.

Pro Builder describes it as a product that needs no mechanical fasteners and protects places where water collects, such as valleys, vent penetrations, chimneys and skylights. If you have ever chased a leak at a valley, our article on roof valley leaks shows why that spot gets special treatment.

It is typically the most expensive of the three per square foot, which is why it is often used in targeted areas rather than across the whole roof. It also bonds firmly to the deck, so it is harder to remove later and cannot be repositioned once stuck.

Felt vs. synthetic underlayment at a glance

This is the comparison most homeowners want. The figures below come from the Angi cost guide cited above.

Feature Asphalt-saturated felt Synthetic
Typical cost per sq. ft. $0.05 to $0.45 $0.15 to $0.70
Typical lifespan Up to 30 years 25 to 50 years
Water resistance Lower Higher
Tear resistance Prone to tearing Stronger
Weight Heavier Lighter, more coverage per roll
Installation Simple and familiar Follow manufacturer fastening rules
Vapor behavior Lets moisture pass Often blocks vapor

The cost gap looks small per square foot, but a typical house has many hundreds of square feet of deck. Even so, underlayment is a modest slice of a full roof replacement bill. The shingles, labor, and tear-off dominate. That is why skimping here rarely saves much, and why a weak layer can cost more than it saves if it fails under a long-lived shingle.

Peel-and-stick underlayment: where it goes

Many homeowners search for peel-and-stick on its own, so here is the practical picture. ARMA’s technical bulletin says self-adhering membranes are primarily used to stop water from ice dams at eaves in cold climates. In Texas, ice dams are rarely the concern. The same bulletin notes these membranes are used successfully in other critical spots, including valleys and around penetrations like skylights and vent stacks. They are also commonly applied across the entire deck on lower-sloped roofs (2:12 to 4:12), and may cover the whole roof in high-wind or hurricane-prone areas.

In Baytown, that last point is the one that matters. A full or partial peel-and-stick layer is a reasonable way to harden a roof against storm-driven rain.

Here is where peel-and-stick usually goes on a shingle roof:

  1. Valleys, where two roof planes shed water into a channel.
  2. Eaves, the lower edge where water runs off and wind can push it up.
  3. Around vents, chimneys and skylights, where flashing meets the roof surface.
  4. Low-slope sections, where water drains slowly.
  5. The full deck, in high-wind areas or where the code or the homeowner asks for it.

Huber Engineered Woods says its ZIP System peel-and-stick products can be used in valleys, eaves, transitions, or across the entire roof, and that they meet ASTM D1970, the standard for self-adhering ice barrier and underlayment sheets. ARMA adds that newer codes expect these products to carry a label showing ASTM D1970 compliance, so look for that label on the roll.

One caution if you choose to cover the whole deck: ARMA notes that ventilation becomes increasingly important when self-adhering underlayments cover the entire roof deck, because poor ventilation can lead to condensation and early deterioration of the roof system.

What is the best underlayment for shingles?

There is no single winner, because the best choice depends on your roof’s slope, your climate, how long you plan to stay, and your budget. Use these questions:

  • How long do you want the roof to last? Architectural shingles are commonly rated for 25 to 30 years. A synthetic layer is designed to last through that span, while felt is rated up to about 30 years at best. Pairing a long-lived shingle with the weakest layer beneath it leaves a gap.
  • How much wind and rain does your area see? On the Gulf Coast, sealing around nail holes and valleys is worth the extra dollars. Peel-and-stick at the vulnerable spots, with synthetic or felt over the rest, is a common approach.
  • How low is your slope? Low-slope sections drain slowly, so they benefit most from a sealed membrane.
  • What does your warranty require? Shingle manufacturers can set underlayment requirements for their system warranties. Confirm them before the job.
  • What does your attic ventilation look like? A tighter underlayment calls for proper airflow. See our ventilation guide.

For a budget replacement, quality felt installed correctly is a legitimate code-compliant layer. For a house you plan to keep, synthetic is the safer long-term layer, with peel-and-stick added at valleys, eaves and penetrations.

If you are weighing shingles against other roof coverings, our comparison of asphalt shingles vs. metal roofing in Texas covers that decision, since the underlayment under metal is chosen differently.

Texas rules and insurance: what has changed

If you live in the Texas coastal counties, underlayment is now more than a preference. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) announced that, effective April 1, 2026, it adopted the 2024 IBC and IRC as the minimum construction standards for wind and hail insurance through the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA). Those are the International Building Code and International Residential Code, the model codes that many cities build on.

In the TWIA catastrophe area, TDI says underlayment for asphalt shingle and modified bitumen roofs must follow one of three methods:

  1. Two mechanically fastened layers.
  2. Self-adhering ASTM D1970 strips at least 4 inches wide over all roof-deck joints, followed by one layer of underlayment.
  3. One full layer of ASTM D1970 self-adhering underlayment.

Two of the three options involve peel-and-stick. Whether your address falls inside the catastrophe area, and what your own policy requires, is a question for your insurer or agent. ARMA also advises always checking local building codes to confirm eave protection requirements and whether a self-adhering membrane is acceptable across a full lower-sloped or high-wind roof.

The practical takeaway: if a storm damages your roof and you file a claim, the underlayment on the rebuilt roof may need to meet current standards, not the ones that were in place when your house was built. Ask for the layer to be listed in writing.

How to compare underlayment in a roofing estimate

Many estimates say only “underlayment included.” That phrase can hide a 15-pound felt on one bid and a full peel-and-stick layer on another, at very different prices. Before you compare totals, look for:

  • The type and weight: felt (15 or 30 pound), synthetic, or self-adhering, with the product name.
  • Where it goes: whole deck, or specific areas such as valleys and eaves.
  • How it is fastened: synthetic products have their own fastening instructions.
  • Standards listed: ASTM D1970 for self-adhering products, for example.
  • Ventilation notes: especially if the deck will be fully covered.

Our walkthrough on how to read and compare roofing estimates shows how to line up bids so you are comparing the same job.

Commercial roofs use different membranes

If you manage a flat or low-slope commercial building, the layers under and in the roof look different. Single-ply membranes and modified bitumen are chosen as the waterproofing layer itself, not as hidden underlayment. Our comparisons of TPO vs. EPDM and TPO vs. modified bitumen explain those options, and our commercial roof types guide helps you match a system to your building.

Roof help from Sure Claim Roofing

We are a locally owned roofing company in Baytown, and we work on repairs, full replacements and storm damage for homes and commercial properties, including asphalt shingle, metal, tile and TPO roofs. Our inspections are free and carry no obligation, and we explain your options with photo documentation so you can see what we see. If storm damage is behind your roof problem, we also help with insurance claim documentation and assistance.

Sureclaimroofing

If you are planning a new roof, start with our roof replacement page, or book a free roof inspection and we will go over what is under your shingles and what your roof needs. We are available seven days a week.

FAQ

Is synthetic underlayment better than felt?

In most comparisons, yes, on water resistance, tear strength and weight. Synthetic is also rated for a longer life, 25 to 50 years versus up to 30 for felt, according to Angi. It costs more per square foot and needs careful fastening, so the best choice depends on your budget and how long you will keep the roof.

Can I use peel-and-stick on the whole roof?

Yes, in many cases. ARMA notes that self-adhering membranes are commonly applied over the entire deck on lower-sloped roofs and may cover the whole roof in high-wind areas. Check your local code and your attic ventilation first.

Does felt or synthetic underlayment need to be replaced with the shingles?

The underlayment is installed during a roof replacement, after the old shingles come off. Because it sits directly under the new shingles, it is normally part of the same job. A roofer can inspect your deck during a tear-off and confirm what goes down.

What underlayment does Texas wind code call for?

For homes in the TWIA catastrophe area, TDI’s 2024 code update sets three allowed methods, including two that use ASTM D1970 self-adhering underlayment. Details are in the TDI bulletin. Ask your insurer which standards apply to your address.

Sources

Have a question about your roof?

Book Your Free Inspection

See What Your Roof Should Cost in About a Minute

Type your address, and we measure your roof from satellite imagery and show you a real price range. Know your number before you talk to your insurance company.

Free. No obligation. Your price appears instantly online.

See your roof price in 60 seconds

Type your address. We measure your roof from satellite imagery and show you a real price range. Free, and no salesman visit required.

Prefer to talk to a person? Book a free inspection